Isnāt the GWWC Pledge too simplistic to fit everyoneās specific situation?
Another thing that I think is worth mentioning here is that the GWWC pledge is already less one-size-fits-all than many people realise. To illustrate, here are some key points from their FAQ:
The pledge is of course just a minimum. Some members decide to go further than this and pledge to give a higher percentage, such as 20% or even 50%.
[...]
What do you mean by income?
The goal here is to help members stick to their plan of taking significant action to benefit others. All guidelines about how to calculate income should be thought of as serving that goal. [Then there are more details on this.]
[...]
Students, unemployed people, and full-time parents
Many students, unemployed people and full-time parents have little or no income, but are largely supported by money from family members, the government or a student loan.
The Pledge does not require you to donate any of this funding (although it does commit you regarding any future income). However, in the interests of all of our members giving what they can, we feel that the spirit of the Pledge requires them to donate at least 1% of their spending money.
We define spending money as money received for the purpose of spending on items such as food, rent, travel, children, or personal items. It does not include spending on tuition fees. If a couple with shared finances both wish to join, then they can simply donate 10% of their combined earnings and not worry about spending money.
Of course, people who earn some income but depend on other help for their living expenses may choose to donate 10% of their earnings if they want to go above and beyond.
[...]
How often should members donate?
The spirit of the Pledge is to donate on an ongoing basis, rather than letting ādonation debtā build up over many years. We check in with members every year and encourage them to log their donations. However, you donāt have to donate on a strictly annual basis. Members who consolidate donations into certain years (for example for tax advantages, or in case of temporary financial hardship) are welcome to do so.
Do donations have to be to registered charities?
The commitment is to donate to āthe most effective organisationsā. These organisations could be charities, but could also be entities not officially registered as tax-deductible charities (for example a charity in the early stages of getting registered, or an advocacy or lobbying group that is not a charity.)
Thanks for putting this together!
Another thing that I think is worth mentioning here is that the GWWC pledge is already less one-size-fits-all than many people realise. To illustrate, here are some key points from their FAQ: