I hope that karma isn’t a signal of disagreement! We’ve always had norms of karma being a signal for good and bad content, and explicitly not about whether you agree or disagree with someone. I definitely upvote many things I disagree with, and downvote many things that argue badly for conclusions I agree with.
I hope that karma isn’t a signal of disagreement! We’ve always had norms of karma being a signal for good and bad content, and explicitly not about whether you agree or disagree with someone. I definitely upvote many things I disagree with, and downvote many things that argue badly for conclusions I agree with.
This seems fair—though I would hope there would be significant overlap between ‘I agree with this’ and ‘this is a good argument’.
I agree with all of this.