Hmmmm this still feels like a bit of a dodge. If the work is all public, what specific thing has Simon missed or misunderstood or what are you going to change? Let’s give it two weeks, but if there is no secret info there ought to be an answer to that question.
Also, what do you expect the results of the RCT to be? And if you think they will be negative shouldn’t you remove the recommendation now?
Hi Nathan, I don’t think the results of the RCT will be negative, just that they could cause us to update (in either direction) which adds uncertainty, though I’d admit that at a <50% forecast this could plausibly increase my forecast rather than lower it (though this isn’t immediately clear; depends on the interactions with the other reasons).
And I hope the more elaborate reply I just wrote to Simon answers your remaining question.
Hmmmm this still feels like a bit of a dodge. If the work is all public, what specific thing has Simon missed or misunderstood or what are you going to change? Let’s give it two weeks, but if there is no secret info there ought to be an answer to that question.
Also, what do you expect the results of the RCT to be? And if you think they will be negative shouldn’t you remove the recommendation now?
Props for engaging here.
Hi Nathan, I don’t think the results of the RCT will be negative, just that they could cause us to update (in either direction) which adds uncertainty, though I’d admit that at a <50% forecast this could plausibly increase my forecast rather than lower it (though this isn’t immediately clear; depends on the interactions with the other reasons).
And I hope the more elaborate reply I just wrote to Simon answers your remaining question.