But these three rankings are inconsistent, and one of them should go. To endorse all
of them means to breach transitivity. Is EA committed to rejecting transitivity? This
view is very controversial, and if EA required it, this would need serious inquiry and
defence.
These rankings do not seem inconsistent to me? C^^ > B > C^ > C
edit: substituted with ‘^’ due to formatting issues.
I cannot see the inconsistency there either, the whole section seems a bit strange as his “no death” example starts also containing death again about half way through.
(Note your first line seems to be missing some *’s)
These rankings do not seem inconsistent to me? C^^ > B > C^ > C
edit: substituted with ‘^’ due to formatting issues.
I cannot see the inconsistency there either, the whole section seems a bit strange as his “no death” example starts also containing death again about half way through.
(Note your first line seems to be missing some *’s)
Fixed, thanks.
I also had some difficulty understanding what he was arguing here.