I’ve changed my mind a bit. I think you’re right you aren’t trying to exaggerate the stats—UBOS is the problem here more than the media or anyone else. I’m now going to have to consider UBOS statisticians non-serious, which is quite problematic (I might even write a post about this given how terrible their work has been here). Thanks for sending me that video—others should watch it too so you can see what I mean. It blew my mind that the “statisticians” who as you say should be the best in the country, appear not to understand their own survey.
They srart with this bizarre statement
“The proportion of people who are poor increases from 8 million to 8.3 million people”
Then it gets worse from there...
UBOS makes at least 3 completely false statements in that video, compared to their official report.
To reiterate one more time, the UBOS report states extreme poverty rates in one part of the report in 2019/2020 at 66.7% in Acholi, 65.7% in Karamoja, and 29.4% in Busoga. Because the population in Busoga is so much higher than either Acholi or Karamoja (more than double the population), the Busoga region has the highest total number of extremely poor people of any region in the country, which is where the confusion comes in. So Busoga region itself is less poor than other parts of Uganda, even though it has a higher total number of poor people—not the easiest thing to understand.
I just want to chime in to say how lovely it is to see a disagreement on the internet that doesn’t degrade. It was very nice to read each of you describe what you believe to be true, cite sources, explain reasoning without exaggerations or ad hominems, consider context and hypothesize about possibilities, and move a step closer to ‘truth.’ Bravo.
Hey Anthony
I’ve changed my mind a bit. I think you’re right you aren’t trying to exaggerate the stats—UBOS is the problem here more than the media or anyone else. I’m now going to have to consider UBOS statisticians non-serious, which is quite problematic (I might even write a post about this given how terrible their work has been here). Thanks for sending me that video—others should watch it too so you can see what I mean. It blew my mind that the “statisticians” who as you say should be the best in the country, appear not to understand their own survey.
They srart with this bizarre statement
“The proportion of people who are poor increases from 8 million to 8.3 million people”
Then it gets worse from there...
UBOS makes at least 3 completely false statements in that video, compared to their official report.
To reiterate one more time, the UBOS report states extreme poverty rates in one part of the report in 2019/2020 at 66.7% in Acholi, 65.7% in Karamoja, and 29.4% in Busoga. Because the population in Busoga is so much higher than either Acholi or Karamoja (more than double the population), the Busoga region has the highest total number of extremely poor people of any region in the country, which is where the confusion comes in. So Busoga region itself is less poor than other parts of Uganda, even though it has a higher total number of poor people—not the easiest thing to understand.
https://www.ubos.org/wp-content/uploads/publications/06_2021UNHS2019-20_presentation.pdf
I would love to have a chat to discuss this more if you have time today or anther day, I’ll send you a message with my phone number.
Nick
I just want to chime in to say how lovely it is to see a disagreement on the internet that doesn’t degrade. It was very nice to read each of you describe what you believe to be true, cite sources, explain reasoning without exaggerations or ad hominems, consider context and hypothesize about possibilities, and move a step closer to ‘truth.’ Bravo.
Thanks too Joseph, for appreciating this. Anthony.