Formerly Executive & Professional Assistant Contractor at Effective Ventures Operations
Currently ETG as a Owner of Stellaire Dental Center
Arvin
Karma: 438
oh what a great way to put it and thanks for posting this. I share about better giving for fun so I haven’t sit myself down to really thinking about it deeply though I’ve been thinking about this in passing for a long time now.
I experience these problems often when i’m sharing about EA. My angle was off even to me but I couldn’t point a finger to it. These feel like you hit the nail on the head.
- “It gets at what the target audience really wants to feel — confidence in impact — without making them do something many aren’t ready for: comparing different ways of doing good.”
Yeah, i admit i made many people’s eye glaze over with just a sentence or so in about the “fun” nuaces of this.
- “It avoids the reading “everybody else is doing this wrong and we’re doing it right”.
When I made this mistake, others BS alarms were blaring out and disengaged.
- “It doesn’t attack previous donation decisions.”
With some charitable ones, I didn’t even talk about it as I didn’t quite know how to go about it without slighting their previous/current donations.
- “puts the viewer outside of the problem, looking in. It makes them a problem-solver, rather than putting them on the defensive. And if they see themselves reflected, they have the company of millions rather than feeling like they’re in the hot seat.”
What a valuable skill this would be for EA comms to do more of. Looking forward to the next GWWC comms piece
“Lemiently Stoic”
ATPs: Advocate for Top Public Service
Public Service instead of Charities because not all Public Service is a Charity and not all Charities are Public Service.
ATP, Adenosine Triphosphate, is present in all humans and all forms of life. It is a key part in every thought, change, growth of all beings now, and in the future.
ATP, Advocate for Top Public Service, can be present in all works for humanity for all forms of life. It can be a key part in every thought, change and growth of all beings now. and in the future.
Thank you for writing this, Tobias. I can see why you feel confused about this, I think it makes sense to feel so. It sucks your friends made you feel bad about it.
I can’t say what the right thing to do was in that situation, but I can say I am with you that it isn’t right to be harsh to ourselves and others for not making the most optimized decision all the time.
No one needs help just because they spend their personal time and money on a stray dog, including you. I can see why this might still be hard to accept. Perhaps reframing it like this might help?Your compassionate colleague, who’s incredibly dedicated to improving animal welfare, was on vacation. They’re resting from difficult work and making difficult decisions.
They gave themselves rare time to do whatever they wanted to do, to focus on themselves, just enjoying their lives.
And at that time, helping an incredibly friendly and trusting stray dog would make them happy. And so, they did.
I currently live in a place where there are a lot of suffering people and animals. Most of the time, I can’t help them. I try to not ignore them, though; I acknowledge them in ways I can. I think they really appreciate that. When I say no to people begging, I still kindly look them in the eye and smile to say sorry. For strays, I give them small treats.
Since I can’t avoid it, I cope by reframing it as a daily reminder of why this work means so much. That I’m helping this many beings who are in need, if not more.
It hurts that I’m affected, but I see it as an indication that I still care. I think I would actually be really worried if I am no longer affected.
Yes! I got long COVID for many months and needed to reduce my work hours significantly. It’s under-researched, and there was very little I could do about it.
I can’t imagine how debilitating ME/CFS are. Averting that, too, would be so wonderful.
If true, this is insanely amazing!
As someone who lives in a 3rd world country where dengue is endemic and the healthcare systems’ treatments and testing are outdated (understandably, as they are super stretched), this would be such an immense relief for us!
It never really sinks in when I learned about this until I had to experience it first hand when I got a 40C/104F fever 2 weeks ago.
Most hospitals were full. I was finally brought to a private one, but they gave me the wrong dengue test, the wrong medication, the wrong reading of my x-ray and despite being on a stretcher, they couldn’t admit me or refer me to the nearest hospital either as they were both over their capacity.
It’s not uncommon to take 20-30 hours sitting at the hospital hall before being able to be admitted, if at all.
Then, the costs charged after are way out of reach for most people, even in a public hospital. Most families, even the ones I know who are well off and have doctors in their families, end up in debt for years.
400 million infections per year.
The potential of alleviating so much suffering makes me teary-eyed with happiness. Cross fingers that this goes well!
If I’m not mistaken and in case anyone was unsure what GHW meant (me), it likely stands for Global Health and Wellbeing.
*mindlessly typed eaforum
”wth, why comic sans”
″oh, haha funny”
*try find more funny in the community tab
*sees Nathan’s post about the new time article
*sad, confused, dizzy huhu
*comic sans softened the blow though
”ty online team.”
“drama curfew when?”
Also, I love the gel sleeping mat was mentioned because I also recommend that to people (alongside an affordable memory foam topper). It really helps with sleep, general sharpness, mood and electricity bills!
Thank you for taking the time to write this. I love how this was written too. It’s in a way where I don’t feel like something is being sold to me and it’s just a genuine reflection of why EA is still really wonderful.
I at times honestly forget why this movement/community is uniquely valuable. But when I remember, they’re enough to keep me hopeful again. As you mentioned, being truly empowered, taking corrective actions are the norm, collective learning etc. all these aspects of the community/movement are still here. They help reassure me that we will continue to do better. Thank you for sharing and helping remind us all.
I drafted/privated my shortform about asking for people’s input about the perspectives I had with the current issues on my own because I need to take a break from the forum and focus on the real impactful work I’m doing. Plus, counterfactually, there’s an 80% chance someone else will post something similar and better written anyway.
A very valid concern. Thankfully, if I’m not mistaken, the moderators block troll votes (70% confidence) and have done so already in the past (50% confidence).
F. Should I post this as a question instead? (I’m afraid I’ll be taking away attention or look like I’m collecting karma)
E. Am I just super biased hence why I think this?
D. Community health, a more thorough case as a cause area to help the longevity of the community/movement?
C. Would we prefer a separate org/service that prevents these and work closely with CEA instead? Minimize conflict of interests?
B. At this point, do we want CEA to do this?
A. Will CEA have the capacity/time and experience to do it right?
To make it easier for people to give their takes, I’ll list the questions here in the comments so if you have no time, you can just vote to agree or disagree and that would already greatly help me. Thank you to everyone who has voted so far.
Kathleen was wonderful to work with back at EV. I looked forward to tackling problems with as she did so effectively and systematically, prioritizing really well. She embodied the anchor during the FTX storm and made my job easier by doing so. Super happy for her! Also thanks to Frances for creating this, hopes it helps people to consider transitioning if they find a fit.