I’m an Indian guy with a JD-equivalent honors degree and also a masters degree in corporate law. I worked as an outsourced in-house counsel (contract review and drafting) at Ernst & Young/EY for (two American and one British) Fortune 500 companies. After that I burnt out and quit.
I saw the rather heart-wrenching effects of the pandemic first-hand in New Delhi and did my first “philanthropy” by financially supporting and encouraging neighbors to support domestic helps whose income had evaporated overnight due to the lockdowns.
I was inspired by Bill Gates’ work during the pandemic. I don’t come from money so I thought of joining the Indian Administrative Service, India’s high-impact federal bureaucracy which controls the administration of India’s $756 billion annual federal budget. But I wasn’t successful and now I’m an independent lawyer, looking to go back to a job.
I got to know about EA from Scott Alexander’s blog and read WWOTF and started lurking on the forum. I’m interested in animal welfare, AI safety, geopolitics, government policy, improving mental health resources and progress studies.
You make good points. Obviously, every country is either definitionally or practically a nation-state. But IMHO the only conditions under which individual freedoms and economic freedoms for individuals survive in a country, are when Statism is not embraced but is instead held at arm’s length and treated with caution and hesitation.
My argument for voting against Trump and Trumpists in the 2026 midterms, for a republican-leaning American citizen is this:
The current situation is directly a result of both Republican and Democrat politicians explicitly trying to increase and abuse state power for their definition of “the greater good”, which the other side disagrees with.
Up to an arbitrary point, this can be considered the ordinary functioning of democratic nation-states. Beyond the arbitrary point, the presence or absence of democracy is irrelevant, and the very nature of the social contract changes.
The fact that the arbitrary point is unknown or unpredictable is precisely the reason that Statism should not embraced but instead be held at arm’s length and treated with caution and hesitation!
Every dollar the government takes out of you pocket or restricts you from earning, every sector or part of the economy or society the government feels the need to “direct” or “reshape” for the greater good, the less freedom there is for the individual, and private citizens as a whole.
If the Republican voters abdicate too much sovereignty to support Trumpist pet projects, even if the Dems ultimately defeat Trumpists, or even if Vance turns out to be a much better president, the social contract may or may not revert back to what it used to be. Which could really suck.