This is a great postâthanks, Frances! This comes up a lot in my conversations about EA, and I really appreciate the clarity youâve brought to it.
One line that really stood out to me was:
âAnd shouldnât everyone have the organs that they so desperately need?â
I think it can be useful to acknowledge that the answer to this question is a clear yes. When I talk to people about triage, I always try to acknowledge that, ideally, we wouldnât have to make these trade-offs at all. Our ultimate goal isnât to help only those above a certain thresholdâitâs to help everyone.
We prioritise not because we think some lives matter more, but because we wish we could help everyone.
itâs hard to know without (a) what the counterfactual is for the forum team, and (b) some impact stories/â botecs/â indications of what debate weeks have resulted in.