Search, subforums, and other Forum updates (October 2022)
It’s only been around a month since our last update post, but we have a bunch of new features for everyone. A quick summary of the updates:
We’ve significantly updated the Forum search feature ⬇️
Two pilot subforums have launched ⬇️
The site is now ~25% faster ⬇️
September was a month of record usage on the Forum ⬇️
Some other changes and updates ⬇️
As a reminder, if you have any feature requests or suggestions, you’re very welcome to share them on the feature suggestion thread (or to get in touch). If you have comments or questions about anything here, you can also just leave a comment on this post.
An updated search feature
We have a new search UI! This is hopefully easier to use, and it also lets you filter by date, topic, and a couple of other things. You can also exclude terms by writing phrases like “Forum -update” (to search for things that include the word “Forum” but exclude the word “update”), and search for specific phrases by using quotation marks.
For now, filtering is only possible on desktop. You can access the search feature by typing something into the search bar that appears at the top right corner of your Forum window and hitting enter, or just going to this link.
This update doesn’t incorporate all the suggestions we’ve received, but it’s a start. If you have other suggestions – particularly if there are instances where the old UI was better for you – please let us know! We might not implement your suggestions right away, as we’re focusing on some unrelated projects right now, but we’d love to hear them and may prioritize them.
Two pilot subforums: bioethics and software engineering
As the amount of content on the Forum grows, we want to help people to engage with the content that is most relevant and helpful for them.
One approach we are exploring is subforums, and we launched our first pilot subforum (the bioethics subforum) last month. We later launched a software engineering subforum and will likely be rolling out more subforums over time. The direction we take will depend on how these pilots go.
We are continually adding features to the subforums, and your feedback is always appreciated!
Performance improvements
We’ve made a number of technical changes that improve the site’s performance. For instance, the Frontpage should now load around 25% faster.
We’ve also had a couple of brief outages recently, which caused some distress. We fixed an issue with our deployment process which should prevent this from happening in the future.
Record usage
The Forum has continued its rapid growth, and September hit records in every single engagement metric we track; total views, number of logged-in users, number of comments, number of accounts created with at least 5 posts viewed, number of posts with at least 2 upvotes, number of unique voters, total votes, and the number of monthly active users. The final day of the EA Criticism Contest also led to the highest single engagement day in Forum history.
Thanks all for using the Forum!
Other changes and updates
We are changing the Forum’s license
Sharang Phadke joined the forum team as a product manager
Our test “ask everyone anything” thread seems to be a success – 211 comments at the moment
Subscribing to the new subforums adds a tag to the user’s profile, see below.
This reads like a career/attribute tag.
I suspect people might read into this tag inappropriately, e.g. associating them with the skills/experiences/perspectives of being a SWE, when the person may not be a SWE at all or have any of these traits.
Also as a UX thing, getting a publicly viewable side effect of a subscription seems unexpected and out of the norm.
It’s still there!
This is association is harmful for my EA forum experience. Pls fix senpai.
This week, someone correctly used “race condition” in a reply.
If you click on your name in the top right corner, then click edit profile, you can scroll down and delete tags under “my activity” by clicking the x on the right side of each block.
Yes! Thank you!
Wait!
Unfortunately, this doesn’t work, this unjoined me.
Hooray. Love the yellow six-legged triceratops. (Or is that one a biceratops? hmm or diceratops?)
Important clarification: the bi?ceratops has five feet! Much like Lamassu:
The welcome message for the sub-forums seems like it should be dismissable as it is too much of an attention grabber to be there all the time.
Below is one case where EA Forum dark mode might be failing.
Might be a minor CSS/”missed one case” sort of thing .
https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG/ben_west-s-shortform
The forum feels a bit cleaner these last few days. Maybe because there are fewer pinned / curated posts. I think I still like the <https://www.lesswrong.com/> or <https://ea.greaterwrong.com/> frontpages better (no pinned posts, or just one).
Personally, I’ve moved to mostly using <https://newsboat.org/> (an RSS reader) to browse new posts, rather than visiting the frontpage.
I don’t think that the above implies any particular course of action for forum maintainers, because they might be optimizing for the general majority. But for readers who really like clean interfaces, these other frontends might be worth looking into.
Excited about better search!
Two questions regarding license:
Maybe the license/copyright info should be mentioned somewhere prominent, like at the bottom of every page? I can’t see anything of the sort on mobile.
What’s the current license that we’re transitioning away from?
Thanks!
The new license requirement doesn’t start until December 1; when that starts we will think through how to display it. My current guess is that it shouldn’t be very prominent because it’s not something that most viewers will care about. Interested to hear push back on that if you disagree.
There is no license currently.