RSS

Cash transfers

TagLast edit: 19 Aug 2022 20:50 UTC by Pablo

Cash transfers are direct payments, typically by governments or nonprofits, made to eligible groups of people.

Three main types of cash transfer programs have been studied: conditional cash transfers (CCTs), unconditional cash transfers (UCTs), and business grant programs.

GiveWell considers cash transfers to have the strongest track record of any non-health intervention, and estimates cash transfer programs to be in the same range of cost-effectiveness as their other priority programs.[1] As they acknowledge, this assessment is highly sensitive to certain empirical and moral assumptions, particularly concerning the investment returns to cash transfers and the relative value of averting child mortality vis-à-vis improving adult income.

Cash transfers as a benchmark

An important use of cash transfers, pioneered by GiveDirectly and championed by GiveWell, is as a benchmark for comparing the value of different causes and for deciding whether to fund certain charities. Cash transfers are especially attractive as a benchmark because (1) they are “massively scalable”[2] and (2) their cost-effectiveness can be straightforwardly expressed as a multiplier, given plausible assumptions about the relationship between money and wellbeing. Specifically, if a doubling of income confers roughly the same benefit to people regardless of income level—as life satisfaction surveys appear to suggest—, then the average citizen of a rich nation can expect to accomplish about 100 times as much by making a cash transfer to someone living in extreme poverty than by donating that money locally or keeping it to herself. This is because people in extreme poverty earn about 100 times less than people in rich countries do on average, so a donation that can double the income of one rich person can also double the income of about 100 extremely poor people.[3][4]

Further reading

Carter, Samantha (2019) Are cash transfers the best policy option?, Effective Altruism Global, October 20.

Devereux, Stephen (2002) Social protection for the poor: lessons from recent international experience, working paper no. 142, Institute of Development Studies.

Evans, David K. & Anna Popova (2017) Cash transfers and temptation goods, Economic Development and Cultural Change, vol. 65, pp. 189–221.

Fiszbein, Ariel & Norbert Schady (2009) Conditional Cash Transfers: Reducing Present and Future Poverty, Washington, D.C.: The World Bank.

GiveWell (2012) Cash transfers, GiveWell, December (updated November 2018).

Molina Millán, Teresa et al. (2019) Long-term impacts of conditional cash transfers: review of the evidence, The World Bank Research Observer, vol. 34, pp. 119–159.

Pega, Frank et al. (2017) Unconditional cash transfers for reducing poverty and vulnerabilities: effect on use of health services and health outcomes in low- and middle-income countries, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, issue 11, art. no. CD011135.

  1. ^

    GiveWell (2012) Cash transfers, GiveWell, December (updated November 2018).

  2. ^

    Future Fund (2022) Massively scalable projects, Future Fund, February 25.

  3. ^

    Karnofsky, Holden (2015) Good ventures and giving now vs. later, The GiveWell Blog, November 25.

  4. ^

    Berger, Alexander (2019) Givewell’s top charities are (increasingly) hard to beat, Open Philanthropy, July 9.

Sam Carter: Are cash trans­fers the best policy op­tion?

EA Global9 Jul 2020 14:49 UTC
13 points
1 comment13 min readEA link
(www.youtube.com)

A dozen doubts about GiveWell’s numbers

JoelMcGuire1 Nov 2022 2:25 UTC
134 points
18 comments19 min readEA link
(www.happierlivesinstitute.org)

I was a COVID-19 re­cip­i­ent. Now, I’m an employee

GiveDirectly25 Dec 2021 3:47 UTC
77 points
2 comments3 min readEA link
(www.givedirectly.org)

Cash Trans­fers as a Sim­ple First Argument

TylerMaule17 Apr 2021 15:00 UTC
20 points
4 comments2 min readEA link

Donat­ing money, buy­ing hap­piness: new meta-analy­ses com­par­ing the cost-effec­tive­ness of cash trans­fers and psy­chother­apy in terms of sub­jec­tive well-being

MichaelPlant25 Oct 2021 15:38 UTC
153 points
46 comments18 min readEA link

Our in­no­va­tions in Togo and the fu­ture of cash distribution

GiveDirectly24 Apr 2021 0:52 UTC
29 points
1 comment1 min readEA link
(www.givedirectly.org)

Two Re­quire­ments for Any Welfare Payment

FCCC17 Jun 2020 13:07 UTC
6 points
0 comments1 min readEA link

Don’t wait – there’s plenty more need and op­por­tu­nity today

GiveDirectly24 Nov 2021 14:56 UTC
45 points
15 comments6 min readEA link

The New Hu­man­i­tar­ian: ‘GiveDirectly loses $900,000 in DRC mo­bile cash fraud’

altacc21 Nov 2023 10:35 UTC
4 points
1 comment1 min readEA link
(www.thenewhumanitarian.org)

Send funds to earth­quake sur­vivors in Turkey via GiveDirectly

GiveDirectly2 Mar 2023 13:19 UTC
38 points
1 comment3 min readEA link

$241,633 was lost to fraud this year — that’s about what we expect

GiveDirectly26 Dec 2021 6:08 UTC
62 points
1 comment5 min readEA link
(www.givedirectly.org)

A Bizarre Baraza: Why One Village Re­fused Funds — Then Changed Its Mind

GiveDirectly24 Oct 2019 7:00 UTC
24 points
0 comments6 min readEA link
(www.givedirectly.org)

The elephant in the bed­net: the im­por­tance of philos­o­phy when choos­ing be­tween ex­tend­ing and im­prov­ing lives

MichaelPlant18 Nov 2022 12:09 UTC
150 points
40 comments24 min readEA link
(www.happierlivesinstitute.org)

Work­ing in the U.S. helped us get more money to in­ter­na­tional recipients

GiveDirectly15 Sep 2021 7:13 UTC
97 points
3 comments2 min readEA link
(www.givedirectly.org)

Vox on cash trans­fers vs “grad­u­a­tion pro­grams” for fight­ing ex­treme poverty

Lizka7 Jul 2022 15:09 UTC
29 points
5 comments5 min readEA link
(www.vox.com)

How big are the in­tra-house­hold spillovers for cash trans­fers and psy­chother­apy? Con­tribute your pre­dic­tion for our anal­y­sis.

JoelMcGuire8 Dec 2021 16:37 UTC
15 points
2 comments1 min readEA link

The story of a re­fugee GiveDirectly field officer

GiveDirectly8 Nov 2019 8:00 UTC
9 points
1 comment6 min readEA link
(www.givedirectly.org)

The effect of cash trans­fers on sub­jec­tive well-be­ing and men­tal health

JoelMcGuire20 Nov 2020 18:12 UTC
71 points
9 comments6 min readEA link

How does a ba­sic in­come af­fect re­cip­i­ents dur­ing COVID-19?

GiveDirectly3 Sep 2020 11:01 UTC
19 points
0 comments1 min readEA link

Us­ing Sub­jec­tive Well-Be­ing to Es­ti­mate the Mo­ral Weights of Avert­ing Deaths and Re­duc­ing Poverty

MichaelPlant3 Aug 2020 16:17 UTC
97 points
8 comments35 min readEA link

Moyo—a new or­ga­ni­za­tion offer­ing a UBI to peo­ple in poverty

Amber Dawn22 Sep 2023 10:39 UTC
29 points
0 comments1 min readEA link
(www.givemoyo.com)

Ali­son Fa­hey: Is uni­ver­sal ba­sic in­come a vi­able way to sup­port hu­mans in the face of technology

EA Global2 Jun 2017 8:48 UTC
7 points
0 comments1 min readEA link
(www.youtube.com)

What we’ve learned by com­par­ing cash to job training

GiveDirectly8 Sep 2020 8:37 UTC
17 points
0 comments1 min readEA link
(www.givedirectly.org)

Sam Carter and Joe Hus­ton: The sci­ence be­hind Univer­sal Ba­sic Income

EA Global8 Jun 2018 7:15 UTC
9 points
0 comments16 min readEA link
(www.youtube.com)

Ian Bassin: Ba­sic in­come — the GiveDirectly experiment

EA Global5 Aug 2016 9:19 UTC
7 points
0 comments1 min readEA link
(www.youtube.com)

GiveWell’s recom­men­da­tion of GiveDirectly

William_MacAskill30 Nov 2012 5:00 UTC
2 points
0 comments5 min readEA link

Be­hind the Scenes at a GiveDirectly Call Center

GiveDirectly22 Sep 2019 20:55 UTC
9 points
3 comments6 min readEA link
(www.givedirectly.org)

When Giv­ing Peo­ple Money Doesn’t Help

Zvi 8 Jul 2022 12:00 UTC
45 points
4 comments10 min readEA link

How do cash trans­fers im­pact the peo­ple who don’t re­ceive them?

GiveDirectly4 Dec 2019 12:10 UTC
14 points
2 comments2 min readEA link
(www.givedirectly.org)

The Last Decade: 10 Things We Got Right & Wrong

GiveDirectly22 Oct 2019 1:21 UTC
65 points
0 comments5 min readEA link
(www.givedirectly.org)

Study: AI tar­get­ing helped us reach more peo­ple in poverty

GiveDirectly15 Aug 2021 18:12 UTC
12 points
1 comment2 min readEA link
(www.givedirectly.org)

Ev­i­dence Ac­tion – We’re Shut­ting Down No Lean Sea­son, Our Sea­sonal Mi­gra­tion Pro­gram: Here’s Why

Tessa16 Jun 2019 16:42 UTC
10 points
2 comments7 min readEA link
(www.evidenceaction.org)

Rachel Wad­dell: GiveDirectly’s emer­gency cash re­sponse to COVID-19

EA Global7 Sep 2020 16:28 UTC
4 points
0 comments16 min readEA link
(www.youtube.com)

Ali­son Fa­hey: What we know and don’t know about Univer­sal Ba­sic Income

EA Global3 Nov 2017 7:43 UTC
7 points
0 comments1 min readEA link
(www.youtube.com)

[Question] Look­ing for data on dis­tri­bu­tion of in­come/​wealth over time for ru­ral households

EdoArad15 Mar 2023 10:59 UTC
18 points
3 comments1 min readEA link

Is CBT effec­tive for poor house­holds? Two re­cent pa­pers (eval­u­ated by The Un­jour­nal) with con­trast­ing results

david_reinstein17 Apr 2023 20:46 UTC
38 points
0 comments1 min readEA link
(unjournal.pubpub.org)

[Cross­post] Effec­tive Zakat: Why di­rect cash trans­fers might be the best way to give this year

Muslim Impact Lab17 Apr 2023 20:24 UTC
36 points
3 comments2 min readEA link
(muslimimpactlab.substack.com)

Large Study Ex­am­in­ing the Effects of Cash Trans­fer Pro­grams on Pop­u­la­tion-Level Mor­tal­ity Rates

nshaff3r2 Jun 2023 18:37 UTC
47 points
2 comments1 min readEA link
(www.nature.com)

The im­pact of mo­bile phones & mo­bile money for peo­ple in poverty

GiveDirectly20 Jun 2023 21:27 UTC
76 points
4 comments3 min readEA link

End­ing ex­treme poverty through cash trans­fers should be a cen­tral EA cause

GiveDirectly16 Oct 2023 17:50 UTC
83 points
45 comments4 min readEA link

Rory Ste­wart dis­cusses GiveDirectly on The Rest is Politics

Simon_M7 Apr 2022 13:17 UTC
20 points
14 comments3 min readEA link

Glo Dol­lar, an eth­i­cal sta­ble­coin: model, po­ten­tial im­pact, and roadmap

Jasper Driessens15 Sep 2022 14:20 UTC
21 points
17 comments4 min readEA link

Cash trans­fers are not nec­es­sar­ily wealth transfers

BenHoffman1 Dec 2017 23:35 UTC
17 points
12 comments12 min readEA link

HLI’s Giv­ing Sea­son 2023 Re­search Overview

Happier Lives Institute28 Nov 2023 14:03 UTC
53 points
3 comments19 min readEA link
(www.happierlivesinstitute.org)

Time and time again rich peo­ple ex­ploit the poor

Mindaugas19 Jan 2023 10:52 UTC
−23 points
6 comments1 min readEA link

Hap­piness for the whole house­hold: ac­count­ing for house­hold spillovers when com­par­ing the cost-effec­tive­ness of psy­chother­apy to cash trans­fers

JoelMcGuire14 Apr 2022 20:05 UTC
51 points
1 comment3 min readEA link
(www.happierlivesinstitute.org)

GiveDirectly: New Zealand dona­tion match

Jendayi 1 Mar 2023 14:42 UTC
3 points
0 comments1 min readEA link

GiveWell’s Mo­ral Weights Un­der­weight the Value of Trans­fers to the Poor

Trevor Woolley13 Dec 2022 7:23 UTC
83 points
0 comments5 min readEA link

Ev­i­dence on how cash trans­fers em­power women in poverty

GiveDirectly8 Mar 2023 6:17 UTC
106 points
5 comments1 min readEA link

Early find­ings from the world’s largest UBI study

GiveDirectly6 Dec 2023 22:10 UTC
153 points
7 comments6 min readEA link

Inequal­ity, well-be­ing, and the prob­lem of the un­known re­port­ing function

Barry Grimes9 Dec 2022 16:28 UTC
15 points
0 comments3 min readEA link
(www.pnas.org)

1.5X match for Cana­dian donors to GiveDirectly

Jendayi 22 Dec 2022 13:29 UTC
39 points
5 comments1 min readEA link

Dan Brown: Un­der­stand­ing the gaps be­tween academia and policymaking

EA Global25 Jun 2020 8:48 UTC
14 points
0 comments18 min readEA link
(www.youtube.com)

Mitch Riley: A/​B test­ing for­eign aid

EA Global26 Oct 2018 8:35 UTC
9 points
0 comments1 min readEA link
(www.youtube.com)

Global In­come Coin: a UBI-gen­er­at­ing currency

Jasper Driessens11 May 2022 9:43 UTC
28 points
8 comments5 min readEA link

Against cash bench­mark­ing for global de­vel­op­ment RCTs

Rory Fenton21 Mar 2022 0:29 UTC
116 points
12 comments5 min readEA link

[Question] La­bel­ing cash trans­fers to solve char­coal-re­lated prob­lems?

brb24311 Mar 2022 0:12 UTC
6 points
9 comments1 min readEA link

[Question] How to se­lect un­con­di­tional cash trans­fer benefi­cia­ries to max­i­mize cost-effec­tive­ness (and what in­sti­tu­tional changes can solve re­cip­i­ents’ is­sues)?

brb2437 Jan 2022 22:52 UTC
5 points
0 comments4 min readEA link

Dona­tion Mul­ti­plier Stack­ing: Direct­ing 1.65x to 6.6x More Funds

Tyler Kolota18 May 2022 6:13 UTC
12 points
1 comment4 min readEA link