RSS

Mo­ral patienthood

TagLast edit: Jul 14, 2022, 5:44 PM by Pablo

Moral patienthood is the condition of deserving moral consideration. A moral patient is an entity that possesses moral patienthood.

While it is normally agreed that typical humans are moral patients, there is debate about the patienthood of many other types of beings, including human embryos, non-human animals, future people, and digital sentients.

Moral patienthood should not be confused with moral agency.[1] For example, we might think that a baby lacks moral agency—it lacks the ability to judge right from wrong, and to act on the basis of reasons—but that it is still a moral patient, in the sense that those with moral agency should care about their well-being.

If we assume a welfarist theory of the good, the question of patienthood can be divided into two sub-questions: Which entities can have well-being? and Whose well-being is morally relevant? Each question can in turn be broken down into the question of which characteristics or capacities are relevant and the question of which beings have those capacities.

First, which entities can have well-being? A majority of scientists now agree that many non-human animals, including mammals, birds, and fish, are conscious and capable of feeling pain,[2] but this claim is more contentious in philosophy.[3] This question is vital for assessing the value of interventions aimed at improving farm and/​or wild animal welfare. A smaller but growing field of study considers whether artificial intelligences might be conscious in morally relevant ways.[4]

Second, whose well-being do we care about? Some have argued that future beings have less value, even though they will be just as conscious as today’s beings are now. This reduction could be assessed in the form of a discount rate on future value, so that experiences occurring one year from now are worth, say, 3% less than they do at present. Alternatively, it could be assessed by valuing individuals who do not yet exist less than current beings, for reasons related to the non-identity problem[5] (see also population ethics). It is contentious whether these approaches are correct. Moreover, in light of the astronomical number of individuals who could potentially exist in the future, assigning some value to future people implies that virtually all value—at least for welfarist theories—will reside in the far future[6] (see also longtermism).

Further reading

Animal Ethics (2017) The relevance of sentience, Animal Ethics, September.

Bostrom, Nick & Eliezer Yudkowsky (2014) The ethics of artificial intelligence, in Keith Frankish & William M. Ramsey (eds.) The Cambridge Handbook of Artificial Intelligence, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 316–334.

Kagan, Shelly (2019) How to Count Animals, More or Less, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

MacAskill, W. & Meissner, D. (2020) The expanding moral circle, in Introduction to Utilitarianism.

Muehlhauser, Luke (2017) 2017 report on consciousness and moral patienthood, Open Philanthropy, June.

Tomasik, Brian (2014) Do artificial reinforcement-learning agents matter morally?, arXiv:1410.8233.

Related entries

axiology | consciousness research | moral circle expansion | moral weight | speciesism | valence

  1. ^

    Wikipedia (2004) Distinction between moral agency and moral patienthood, in ‘Moral agency’, Wikipedia, September 25 (updated 14 November 2020‎).

  2. ^

    Low, Philip et al. (2012) The Cambridge declaration on consciousness, Francis Crick Memorial Conference, July 7.

  3. ^

    Allen, Colin & Michael Trestman (2016) Animal consciousness, in Edward Zalta (ed.), Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

  4. ^

    Wikipedia (2003) Artificial consciousness, Wikipedia, March 13 (updated 24 April 2021‎).

  5. ^

    Roberts, M. A. (2019) The nonidentity problem, in Edward Zalta (ed.), Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

  6. ^

Really rad­i­cal empathy

MichaelStJulesJan 6, 2025, 5:46 PM
30 points
3 comments10 min readEA link

Some im­pli­ca­tions of rad­i­cal empathy

MichaelStJulesJan 7, 2025, 4:10 PM
15 points
0 comments7 min readEA link

The Sub­jec­tive Ex­pe­rience of Time: Welfare Implications

Jason SchukraftJul 27, 2020, 1:24 PM
113 points
21 comments63 min readEA link

Toby Ord’s The Scourge, Reviewed

ColdButtonIssuesAug 30, 2022, 9:01 PM
59 points
25 comments4 min readEA link

Com­par­i­sons of Ca­pac­ity for Welfare and Mo­ral Sta­tus Across Species

Jason SchukraftMay 18, 2020, 12:42 AM
102 points
63 comments59 min readEA link

Peter Singer: Non-hu­man an­i­mal ethics

EA GlobalAug 28, 2015, 5:21 PM
9 points
0 comments1 min readEA link
(www.youtube.com)

Hi, I’m Luke Muehlhauser. AMA about Open Philan­thropy’s new re­port on con­scious­ness and moral patienthood

lukeprogJun 28, 2017, 3:49 PM
32 points
66 comments1 min readEA link

Does Crit­i­cal Flicker-Fu­sion Fre­quency Track the Sub­jec­tive Ex­pe­rience of Time?

Jason SchukraftAug 3, 2020, 1:30 PM
68 points
20 comments26 min readEA link

Rad­i­cal Empathy

Holden KarnofskyFeb 16, 2017, 12:41 PM
76 points
15 comments6 min readEA link

How to Mea­sure Ca­pac­ity for Welfare and Mo­ral Status

Jason SchukraftJun 1, 2020, 3:01 PM
71 points
19 comments41 min readEA link

In­ter­view with Jon Mal­latt about in­ver­te­brate consciousness

Max_CarpendaleApr 28, 2019, 5:52 PM
83 points
10 comments11 min readEA link

[Question] Why might one value an­i­mals far less than hu­mans?

IsabelHasseJun 8, 2020, 1:54 AM
28 points
14 comments1 min readEA link

Ja­son Schukraft: Mo­ral stand­ing and cause pri­ori­ti­za­tion

EA GlobalOct 24, 2020, 7:56 PM
9 points
0 comments1 min readEA link
(www.youtube.com)

Differ­ences in the In­ten­sity of Valenced Ex­pe­rience across Species

Jason SchukraftOct 30, 2020, 1:13 AM
94 points
42 comments52 min readEA link

EA read­ing list: util­i­tar­i­anism and consciousness

richard_ngoAug 7, 2020, 7:32 PM
17 points
3 comments1 min readEA link

Up­com­ing AMA with Luke Muehlhauser on con­scious­ness and moral pa­tient­hood (June 28, start­ing 9am Pa­cific)

Julia_Wise🔸Jun 21, 2017, 9:56 PM
13 points
14 comments1 min readEA link

De­sire the­o­ries of welfare and non­hu­man animals

MichaelStJulesJul 16, 2022, 6:52 PM
20 points
5 comments4 min readEA link

Solu­tion to the two en­velopes prob­lem for moral weights

MichaelStJulesFeb 19, 2024, 12:15 AM
66 points
26 comments27 min readEA link

Which an­i­mals re­al­ize which types of sub­jec­tive welfare?

MichaelStJulesFeb 27, 2024, 7:31 PM
22 points
0 comments18 min readEA link

Types of sub­jec­tive welfare

MichaelStJulesFeb 2, 2024, 9:56 AM
42 points
0 comments18 min readEA link

Gra­da­tions of moral weight

MichaelStJulesFeb 29, 2024, 11:08 PM
13 points
0 comments10 min readEA link

LLMs can­not use­fully be moral patients

LGSJul 2, 2024, 4:43 AM
35 points
24 comments4 min readEA link

The Value of Con­scious­ness as a Pivotal Question

Derek ShillerJul 3, 2024, 6:50 PM
71 points
21 comments8 min readEA link

Mak­ing AI Welfare an EA pri­or­ity re­quires jus­tifi­ca­tions that have not been given

JWS 🔸Jul 7, 2024, 9:38 PM
59 points
21 comments6 min readEA link

Re­think Pri­ori­ties’ Digi­tal Con­scious­ness Pro­ject Announcement

Bob FischerJul 5, 2024, 11:15 AM
114 points
4 comments2 min readEA link

Se­quence overview: Welfare and moral weights

MichaelStJulesAug 1, 2024, 4:51 PM
34 points
0 comments1 min readEA link

The scale of an­i­mal agriculture

MichaelStJulesMay 16, 2024, 4:01 AM
49 points
4 comments3 min readEA link

The Welfare of Digi­tal Minds: A Re­search Agenda

Derek ShillerNov 11, 2024, 12:58 PM
53 points
1 comment31 min readEA link

LLMs are weirder than you think

Derek ShillerNov 20, 2024, 1:39 PM
61 points
3 comments22 min readEA link

De­tect­ing Mo­rally Sig­nifi­cant Pain in Non­hu­mans: Some Philo­soph­i­cal Difficulties

Jason SchukraftDec 23, 2018, 5:49 PM
73 points
8 comments22 min readEA link

Why I Think All The Species Of Sig­nifi­cantly De­bated Con­scious­ness Are Con­scious And Suffer Intensely

OmnizoidNov 20, 2024, 4:11 PM
65 points
26 comments33 min readEA link

Cere­bral organoids

ForumiteJul 20, 2022, 8:12 PM
17 points
0 comments1 min readEA link

Is un­der­stand­ing the moral sta­tus of digi­tal minds a press­ing world prob­lem?

Cody_FenwickSep 30, 2024, 8:50 AM
42 points
0 comments34 min readEA link
(80000hours.org)

We should pre­vent the cre­ation of ar­tifi­cial sen­tience

RichardPOct 29, 2024, 12:22 PM
108 points
12 comments15 min readEA link

Key take­aways from Famine, Affluence, and Morality

Emma Richter🔸Sep 14, 2022, 9:02 PM
25 points
3 comments5 min readEA link

New Re­port on Con­scious­ness and Mo­ral Patienthood

lukeprogJun 6, 2017, 1:21 PM
21 points
1 comment2 min readEA link
(www.openphilanthropy.org)

Notes from “Cog­ni­tion, welfare, and the prob­lem of in­ter­species com­par­i­sons”

Barry GrimesNov 16, 2021, 9:17 AM
30 points
0 comments11 min readEA link

Arthro­pod (non) sentience

Arturo MaciasNov 25, 2024, 3:35 PM
−7 points
4 comments4 min readEA link

[Question] How wor­ried should I be about a child­less Dis­ney­land?

Will BradshawOct 28, 2019, 3:32 PM
31 points
8 comments1 min readEA link

The moral ar­gu­ment for giv­ing AIs autonomy

Matthew_BarnettJan 8, 2025, 12:59 AM
33 points
7 comments11 min readEA link

[Question] AI con­scious­ness & moral sta­tus: What do the ex­perts think?

Jay LuongJul 6, 2024, 3:27 PM
0 points
3 comments1 min readEA link

Why an­i­mal char­i­ties are much more effec­tive than hu­man ones

utilitarian01Apr 8, 2019, 5:48 PM
14 points
15 comments2 min readEA link

Oc­to­puses (Prob­a­bly) Don’t Have Nine Minds

Bob FischerDec 12, 2022, 11:59 AM
94 points
19 comments10 min readEA link
(docs.google.com)

Po­ten­tial Fu­ture People

TeddyWJan 8, 2023, 5:20 PM
11 points
6 comments1 min readEA link

Marginal ex­is­tence and its rele­vance to pro-na­tal­ism, longter­mism, and the re­pug­nant conclusion

dawsoneliasenJan 23, 2023, 3:24 AM
4 points
2 comments8 min readEA link

AI safety and con­scious­ness re­search: A brainstorm

Daniel_FriedrichMar 15, 2023, 2:33 PM
11 points
1 comment9 min readEA link

革新的な思いやり

EA JapanJul 26, 2023, 1:35 PM
1 point
0 comments1 min readEA link

Em­pa­tia Radicale

EA ItalyDec 31, 2022, 4:08 AM
1 point
0 comments6 min readEA link

Im­ple­men­ta­tional Con­sid­er­a­tions for Digi­tal Consciousness

Derek ShillerJul 30, 2023, 10:15 PM
35 points
4 comments3 min readEA link