Earn­ing to give

TagLast edit: 8 May 2021 14:12 UTC by EA Wiki assistant

Earning to give is the pursuit of a lucrative career with the purpose of donating a significant portion of the earnings to cost-effective organizations.

The value of earning to give may not be immediately obvious, since people tend to think of ethical jobs as those with a direct positive impact. A useful framing for comparing the social impact of earning to give with that of traditional careers in the nonprofit sector is to consider whether someone pursuing a lucrative career could earn enough to fund at least one nonprofit worker as competent as him- or herself. This will often be the case because there is considerable salary variation across career-types, because money is a fungible resource that can fund many different causes, and because the impact of a charity worker is usually only marginally higher than that of its counterfactual replacement (MacAskill 2014).

Although this approach has sometimes been represented as the highest impact type of career, 80,000 Hours currently believes that it is the best option for only a small proportion of members of the effective altruism community (MacAskill 2015). To a significant extent, this follows from the fact that the most promising causes tend to be talent-constrained rather than funding-constrained (Todd 2015).

The expression earning to save has been suggested for a type of earning to give where earnings are invested for later disbursement rather than donated immediately (Arnold 2018; Todd 2020). A “moderate” version of investing until the end of a person’s career may be contrasted with an “extreme” version of investing for as long as possible (potentially involving many generations, centuries or millennia).


Arnold, Raymond (2018) Earning to save (give 1%, save 10%), Effective Altruism Forum, November 26.

MacAskill, William (2014) Replaceability, career choice, and making a difference, Ethical Theory and Moral Practice, vol. 17, pp. 269–283.

MacAskill, William (2015) 80,000 Hours thinks that only a small proportion of people should earn to give long term, 80,000 Hours, July 6.

Todd, Benjamin (2015) Why you should focus more on talent gaps, not funding gaps, 80,000 Hours, November 27.

Todd, Benjamin (2020) An argument for keeping open the option of earning to save, Effective Altruism Forum, August 31.

Related entries

talent vs. funding constraints

What Is earn­ing to give?

Peter_Hurford26 Jun 2013 4:00 UTC
6 points
0 commentsEA link

The Priv­ilege of Earn­ing To Give

Jeff_Kaufman14 Jan 2015 1:59 UTC
69 points
39 commentsEA link

Salary Ne­go­ti­a­tion for Earn­ing to Give

mulholio3 Apr 2019 12:30 UTC
57 points
28 comments2 min readEA link

Peter Hur­ford thinks that a large pro­por­tion of peo­ple should earn to give long term

Peter_Hurford17 Aug 2015 15:42 UTC
49 points
79 commentsEA link

Earn­ing to give vs. al­tru­is­tic ca­reer choice revisited

Jonah_Sinick28 May 2013 4:00 UTC
2 points
0 commentsEA link

Col­lege and Earn­ing to Give

Jeff_Kaufman16 Dec 2018 20:23 UTC
28 points
10 commentsEA link

Show me the harm

Benjamin_Todd6 Aug 2013 4:00 UTC
7 points
1 commentEA link

Re­place­abil­ity Con­cerns and Pos­si­ble Responses

deluks9172 Aug 2020 18:19 UTC
30 points
7 comments4 min readEA link

Seed fund­ing non­prof­its: a high-risk, high-re­ward ap­proach (Founders Pledge)

KarolinaSarek31 Aug 2020 15:25 UTC
49 points
2 comments5 min readEA link

The Fu­ture of Earn­ing to Give

PeterMcCluskey13 Oct 2019 21:28 UTC
69 points
34 comments10 min readEA link

Money Can’t (Easily) Buy Talent

Mark Xu22 Jan 2021 2:56 UTC
41 points
30 comments12 min readEA link

Earn­ing to Give as Costly Signalling

Raemon24 Jun 2017 16:43 UTC
11 points
5 commentsEA link

Earn­ing to Give v. Pur­su­ing your Pas­sion/​Direct Work

cdc48230 Jul 2016 3:04 UTC
0 points
9 commentsEA link

Giv­ing now vs. later: a summary

Julia_Wise23 Jul 2013 4:00 UTC
27 points
7 comments2 min readEA link

Fi­nance Ca­reers for Earn­ing to Give

kbog6 Mar 2016 5:15 UTC
9 points
14 commentsEA link

Ded­i­cated Donors May Not Want to Sign the Giv­ing What We Can Pledge

MichaelDickens30 Oct 2016 3:26 UTC
15 points
25 commentsEA link

An ar­gu­ment for keep­ing open the op­tion of earn­ing to save

Benjamin_Todd31 Aug 2020 15:09 UTC
34 points
13 comments3 min readEA link

Earn­ing to Give: Pro­gram­ming Lan­guage Choice

Ben_West5 Apr 2015 15:45 UTC
5 points
14 commentsEA link

How im­por­tant is marginal earn­ing to give?

Ben_Kuhn19 May 2015 20:41 UTC
16 points
73 commentsEA link

[Question] What are peo­ple’s ob­jec­tions to earn­ing-to-give?

DonyChristie13 Apr 2019 20:16 UTC
24 points
10 comments1 min readEA link

Should you switch away from earn­ing to give? Some con­sid­er­a­tions.

William_MacAskill25 Aug 2016 22:37 UTC
14 points
81 commentsEA link

[Question] Do we have any recom­men­da­tions for fi­nan­cial ad­visers for earn­ing to give?

jwbayou512 Apr 2019 14:57 UTC
17 points
2 comments1 min readEA link

Vo­ca­tional Ca­reer Guide for Effec­tive Altruists

kbog26 Jan 2019 11:16 UTC
32 points
8 commentsEA link

The Bit­ter­sweet­ness of Re­place­abil­ity

Lila11 Jul 2015 23:44 UTC
15 points
23 commentsEA link

80,000 Hours: Ways to be suc­cess­ful that peo­ple don’t talk about enough

Aaron Gertler31 Jan 2020 9:59 UTC
11 points
1 comment8 min readEA link

Why earn to give? (tran­script)

TopherHallquist19 Sep 2014 20:50 UTC
6 points
5 commentsEA link

Log-nor­mal lamentations

Gregory_Lewis19 May 2015 21:07 UTC
13 points
11 commentsEA link

Lawyer­ing to Give

Jeff_Kaufman25 Sep 2014 12:19 UTC
11 points
14 commentsEA link

Profit­ing-to-Give: har­ness­ing EA tal­ent with a new fund­ing model

andavargas4 Mar 2019 9:22 UTC
25 points
12 comments2 min readEA link

Com­mon re­sponses to earn­ing to give

Ben_Kuhn10 Jun 2013 4:00 UTC
1 point
1 commentEA link

[Question] Direct work vs. earn-to-give

warrenjordan4 May 2020 0:08 UTC
5 points
2 comments1 min readEA link

Why EA meta, and the top 3 char­ity ideas in the space

Joey6 Jan 2021 15:47 UTC
71 points
20 comments10 min readEA link

How I missed my pledge and how I’m fix­ing it

Daniel_Dewey10 Oct 2016 0:06 UTC
21 points
9 commentsEA link

Earn­ing to Save (Give 1%, Save 10%)

Raemon26 Nov 2018 23:47 UTC
67 points
37 comments3 min readEA link

‘I give away half to three-quar­ters of my in­come ev­ery year’ [The Guardian]

Henry_Stanley9 Nov 2019 9:03 UTC
58 points
1 comment1 min readEA link

EAs Should In­vest All Year, then Give only on Giv­ing Tuesday

Cullen_OKeefe10 Jan 2019 21:17 UTC
52 points
24 comments2 min readEA link

The $100trn op­por­tu­nity: ESG in­vest­ing should be a top pri­or­ity for EA careers

Sanjay18 Mar 2021 13:54 UTC
66 points
5 comments7 min readEA link

ESG in­vest­ing isn’t high-im­pact, but it could be

Sanjay18 Mar 2021 14:07 UTC
67 points
5 comments29 min readEA link

Si­mul­ta­neous Shortage and Oversupply

Jeff_Kaufman26 Jan 2019 19:35 UTC
41 points
10 commentsEA link

ESG in­vest­ing is wholly misdirected

Meg16 Apr 2021 15:32 UTC
52 points
2 comments20 min readEA link

To save the world, don’t get a job at a char­ity; go work on Wall Street

William_MacAskill27 Feb 2013 5:00 UTC
2 points
5 commentsEA link

Be­ing a to­bacco CEO is not quite as bad as it might seem

Larks28 Jan 2016 3:59 UTC
10 points
19 commentsEA link

UK In­come Tax & Donations

harald8 Apr 2018 11:40 UTC
40 points
13 commentsEA link
No comments.